Best Director 2000: Tobin Atkinson, A Place in the Sky
Best Acting Company 2001
Best Local Production 2001: The Laramie Project
Best Director 2001: Jerry Rapier, The Laramie Project
Best Actor 2001: Charles Lynn Frost, The Laramie Project
Best Actress 2001: Joyce Cohen, Molly Sweeney
Best Playwright 2001: Moisés Kaufman, The Laramie Project
Best Acting Company 2002
Best Theatre Production 2002: My Left Breast
Best Director 2002: Jerry Rapier, My Left Breast
Best Actress 2002: Betsy West, My Left Breast
Best Playwright 2002: Susan Miller, My Left Breast
Best Theatre Production 2003: Hedwig & The Angry Inch
Best Actor 2003: Aaron Swenson, Hedwig & The Angry Inch
Best Actress 2003: Jeanette Puhich, Hedwig & The Angry Inch
Best Acting Company 2004
Best Theatre Production 2004: Animal Farm
Best Director 2004: Jerry Rapier, Animal Farm
Best Original Play 2004: Slam
Best Acting Company 2005
Best Theatre Production 2005: TRAGEDY: a tragedy
Best Theatre Production 2006: Amerika
Best Original Play 2006: Amerika
Best Unsung Theatre Hero 2006: Cheryl Cluff
Best Arts Fundraiser To Get You Hot Under The Collar 2006: And the Banned Played On
Best Angry Incher 2006: Aaron Swenson, Hedwig and The Angry Inch (revival)
Best Theatre Production 2007: Facing East
Best Original Play 2007: Facing East
Best Theatre Performance 2007: Ensemble of Facing East
Best Instant Theatre 2007: Slam
Best Local Production 2001: The Laramie Project
One of the Year’s Best 2002: My Left Breast
One of the Year’s Best 2003: Hedwig and The Angry Inch
One of the Year’s Best 2004: Animal Farm
One of the Year’s Best 2004: A Letter To Harvey Milk
One of the Year’s Best 2005: Slam ’05
One of the Year’s Best 2005: Hedwig and The Angry Inch (revival)
One of the Year's Best 2006: Amerika
One of the Year's Best 2006: Facing East
One of the Year's Best 2007: Facing East
One of the Year's Best 2007: Exposed
Best Local Production 2001: The Laramie Project
One of the Year’s Best 2002: My Left Breast
Best Fundraiser 2003: And the Banned Played On
Best Drama 2003: bash: latterday plays
Best Actor 2003: Carl Nelson, bash: latterday plays
One of the Year’s Best 2004: A Letter to Harvey Milk
Best Solo Actor 2004: Yaron Schweizer, A Letter to Harvey Milk
One of the Year’s Best 2005: Patient A
One of the Year’s Best 2005: Hedwig and The Angry Inch (revival)
Best Actress 2005: Colleen Lewis, Patient A
One of the Year's Best 2006: Amerika
Best Drama 2006: Facing East
Best Actress 2006: Jayne Luke, Facing East
Best Drama 2007: Exposed
Best Comedy 2007: Gutenberg! The Musical!